Adventure Consultants vs Signature Collection by Gate 1 - Tour Companies Compared
Compare details and see what other travelers are saying.
0 | Poor
Not yet rated
Overall — 4.5
Value — 4.4
Guide — 4.4
Activities — 4.4
Lodging — 5.0
Transportation — 4.9
Meals — 4.9
Overall — 0
Value — 0.0
Guide — 0.0
Activities — 0.0
Lodging — 0.0
Transportation — 0.0
Meals — 0.0
worst experience with guide, ever1.0 December 2018
For my 5-day Mt. Aspiring expedition, I am assigned two guides - JB as main guide and Javier as guide in training. Like me, this is Javier’s first time travelling to New Zealand and first time heading up to Mt Aspiring. In total, Javier had about 1 hour acting as a rope leader, and during this 1 hour, there are three times I think Javier made a wrong / dangerous decision. Would like to give a heads up to all clients going to Aspiring with him this season. Good luck!!!Read more
1. On our third day going up ramp, we all know there is certain avalanche danger due to high freezing level and very deep / soft snow. We actually did get caught by a slush slide when we are close to top of ramp. When leading rope team, Javier however, decides to follow the fall line and go straight up. If there is a slush sliding at that time, it could catch the entire rope team! I think climbers with even little common sense know we should go zig-zag to spread the risk.
2. Still when we are at ramp, there is a small open crevasse on our way up. Javier spent minutes to dig steps on slopes on both side of crevasse and asked me to be very careful to cross it. However, when I was there, three steps left, the crevasse narrows to a line and one normal step could easier across it. Feel Javier doesn’t have much experience dealing with crevasse.
3. On our forth day going back to French right hut. Right after pass, there is a downhill snow slop. In the middle of the slope, there are three crevasse in parallel - middle one coming from left, and the other two coming from right, with quite a bit overlaps. Yes, crevasse is not too narrow, but we are on downhill, a small person like me could cross the middle crevasse with one big step. Feel Javier has some mental issue with crossing crevasse, he instead chose to spend couple minutes navigating narrow snow bridges between those crevasse. Snow are very soft, and he actually fell into snow holes twice when he was on the bridges. Looks really scaring from above.
Other than the above three points, Javier also has some behaviors that might not be dangerous but really annoying:
1. He forgot something EVERY time we went out. Either forget to take crampon or doesn’t have something fixed properly before we left the hut. We have to either go back with him since we are a rope team on glacier, or have to wait couple minutes in freezing cold wind and whiteout condition for this gentleman to get ready. Repeat, EVERY time.
2. When he acted as last person on the rope team, more then half of the time, rope between us are way too loose. I saw at least three times he stood on rope with crampon on. Have to keep coils on hand to adjust rope slackness between us for this `guide`.
3. During some sown hill sections, he could not even catch up with my speed going down. Being pulled couple times.
For JB, I think he really needs to learn how to control his temper and be more considerable to others. On second night, weather forecast is not good for next couple days. Since my main purpose is to do some climbing in Wanaka area (I signed up for SW right but was told not possible when I was in the mountain), I proposed to start walking down on third day and have last day (day 5) doing some multi-pitch rock climb in Wanaka (e.g. Remarkable). As a proposal, I don’t see how it could harm the team. However, JB suddenly gets angry and shouts out
“It’s a shame you think waiting for weather is a waste of time” and
“you like rock climbing? Next time go rock climbing, never do mountaineering again”.
Don’t think it’s proper for a guide to say that.
From day 3, yes, I refused to communicate with JB any more, as I don’t know when I could be shouted again and for what reason. Only two times I had to talk to him.
1. Evening of day 3. We will have a pre-dawn start on day 4 and it was already 8:30pm. I have been on bed for quite a while, but JB and Javier are still chatting loudly in the hut (conversation has nothing to do with this trip). I asked for quiet time. JB refuses and wants me to use ear plug. I believe in all NZ huts, #1 rule is “be quiet when others are sleeping“. Did couple great walks in NZ and spent couple nights in hut. Never met anyone as rude as JB.
2. In French ridge hut, there are only 10 hanging bolts outside of the sleeping area. We have 20+ climbers sleeping in hut that night from at least 5 rope teams. JB took 5 bolts (half of 10) to hang his stuff. I tried to organize them and make space for others, he shouted again and claimed all are his. He himself simply took half of all bolts prepared for all living in the hut.
Do hope JB could be less selfish and more considerable about others, no matter it’s his client and some strangers sharing the same hut.
I have worked with close to 10 group of guides from different background for trekking (EBC, K2BC, Huayhuash etc.) and tech / non-tech climbs. This is my WORST experience, ever.
Tour Adventure Consultants Company Reviews
Thank you for an excellent time.5.0 November 2016
Having just finished the Alpine Expedition Course I would like to say thank you for an excellent time. From Em chasing us with emails with updates to the awesome guides Lydia Bradley and Dean Staples, who were not only highly informative but so much fun to be around with us "aussies". As always AC is a highly professional and caring team towards their clients. Also the food is the best!!Read more
Tour Adventure Consultants Company Reviews
Very organised, Definately recommend5.0 April 2016
Did Aconcagua with them in 2011. Very organised, guides Leo and Mattias were fun. Definately recommend them
Tour Adventure Consultants Company Reviews
|Tours||3 Trips||1 Trip|
|Average Trip Price Per Day||$ 420||$ 0|
|Operator Type||Group Tour Operator||Group Tour Operator|
|Size||Global Operator||Global Operator|
|Headquarters||Wanaka, New Zealand||Fort Washington, Pennsylvania|
Adventure Consultants began in 1992 after two New Zealanders succeeded in climbing the Seven Summits. Today, Adventure Consultants offer a wide range of guided trips made for outdoor enthusiasts looking to push the boundaries of their physical limits.
What Makes Adventure Consultants Stand Out?
- Guided mountain tours
- World-renowned and reputable guides
- Trips for high-intensity active travel (eg. mountain biking, skiing, trekking)
- Small groups
Adventure Consultants proudly emphasizes their guided tours up some of the greatest mountains known to man. Their guided tours up Mount Everest have made them reputable amongst the climbing community, but they also offer destinations around the world. If you are interested in high-intensity active travel, you’ll find a tour right for you. While their main focus is on climbing, they also offer mountain biking, skiing, and trekking.
Their mountain guides are internationally qualified, with some of them being world renowned - so you can be sure you’re in good hands.
Who Will Enjoy Traveling With Adventure Consultants?
Travelers who are...
- looking to combine a love of travel with their love for adrenaline
- Familiar with modern climbing techniques
- Confident performing at high altitudes
- Able to walk for several hours per day through varied terrain
If you live for the thrill that comes with hanging on the edge of a rock, then you’ll love what the Adventure Consultants tours have to offer.
These trips are for people who are willing to train before the tour date, because being in top shape is incredibly important in order to conquer any mountain. Those that choose to go on a climbing tour should also be familiar with modern climbing techniques, and are confident with performing at high altitudes. You’ll be on the move through various terrains for several hours per day. Physical levels do vary from easy to extreme, but be forewarned - easy still means walking for several hours on slightly varied terrain at the very least.
Tours are reasonably priced - while not a budget tour company, the price is understandable for the quality of tour guides, safety, transportation, and food needed to make these trips possible.
- Mt. Everest
- Around the world
Although Adventure Consultants’ Mount Everest tours are what they are most known for, they have trips around the world aimed at exploring the largest summits in every continent. Climb the highest peaks of the world, or trek through remote corners of the world. You’ll spend the majority of your time deep in the mountain ranges, taking in incredible landscapes that many rarely get to experience.
Adventure Consultants Travel Style
These trips are heavily focused on mountaineering and active adventure. Depending on your tour, you may have some free time to explore and do some sightseeing. Accomodation options range from adventurous to “luxurious” - though it’s important to note that their version of luxurious means mid-ranged hotels. Some examples of AC accommodation arrangements include camping at the top of a snow-capped mountain, sleeping in a dormitory style bunk bed, or staying in a cozy 4-star lodge. If you are camping, there won’t be any hot showers or electric outlets, so be prepared with wet wipes and portable chargers.
These destinations are not easy to endure alone, so a team mindset is also incredibly important. You will work as a team to stay warm, carry communal items, and get involved with the meal preparation. Meals are always nutritious and filling since maintaining energy levels is another top priority. Expect to consume 4,000 to 6,000 calories everyday.
Why Choose a Tour With Adventure Consultants?
If you’re an avid climber or active traveler that’s looking for a group to venture with - then you’ve come to the right place. These destinations aren’t easy for most to get to by themselves, nor without a specialised guide. With Adventure Consultants, you know you’ll be fully prepared for your journey and take the right paths along the way.
When deciding to go on a tour with Adventure Consultants, you should remember that every mountaineering journey comes with risks. Not every accident can be foreseen, which is why it’s important to stick together as a group and have experience in the mountains. Since Adventure Consultants’ 1996 Mount Everest accident, they have examined what went wrong and strengthened management in order to ensure it doesn’t happen again.
A unique collection of luxury trips designed by Gate 1 travel.
What Makes Gate 1 Signature Collection Stand Out?
These are luxury minded trips with a local focus. Guides are all local experts, from and living in the destination you’re visiting. Each itinerary features exclusive experiences. Groups are small and each day is full of activity but well balanced.
They focus on offering only a select group of trips in this special collection - allowing them the freedom to create truly spectacular itineraries - which include more inclusions in the price than their other collections.
The tagline is “More Luxury for Less”. These tours may not be in same luxury travel class if you’re used to Abercrombie & Kent, however where comfort and extravagance meets fun and busy travel days of sightseeing and tours, you’ll find Gate 1 Signature Collection.
Who Will Enjoy Traveling with Gate 1 Signature Collection?
Those travelers who are willing to spend a little bit more for a 4-5 star experience, will probably find a sweet spot with Gate 1 Signature tours. These trips tend to be attended by older travelers, in the 50+ range.
Don’t expect too much strenuous activity. You can expect easy paced walks, guided tours and lectures, and stops to explore interesting cultural sites and historical attractions.
While some of these cultural experiences, included in their “Signature Experiences”, are truly unique, be wary that many of these inclusions are fairly standard offerings - such as a hot air balloon ride over the African savannah. So the luxury experience of exclusivity you may be expecting is to be taken with a grain of salt. These tours offer wonderful experiences - but the destinations or activities are not always particularly uncommon or rare.
They currently don’t offer an overly extensive list of countries, but tours do go all over the world. This includes Central Europe, Spain, and the UK, Israel, Jordan and Morocco, Peru, Southeast Asia, Kenya, South Africa, Tanzania, and Zimbabwe.
Gate 1 Signature Collection Travel Style
Signature Collection tours with Gate 1 aim for comfort, ease, and unique cultural experiences. Like their other brands, Gate 1’s Signature Collection is about making sure your sightseeing is maximized, and the price is right for the experience.
Most sightseeing, meals, wifi, tips, and their “Signature Experiences” are included in the itinerary price - unlike Gate 1’s main brand which offers less inclusions. This type of itinerary more helpful to budget travelers wishing to pick and choose which activities they would like to pay for. Gate 1 Signature Tours, however, are best suited to those who want more inclusions and less hassle to have to decide on how to spend their travel time.
Why Choose a Tour with Gate 1 Signature Collection?
If you’re an older traveler looking for a boutique, comfortable, and well paced tour, the Signature tours may suit you very well. Travelers love the customer service, attention to detail, and depth of knowledge the guides bring to each day on the tour. There is also a good balance of free time and optional additional sightseeing opportunities.
All tours feature included “Signature Experiences” which are the main highlights that make the Signature Collection tours stand out from the other Gate 1 brands. These are unique excursions, usually with a strong cultural focus - such as an evening of Irish music in Galway, or a traditional dinner in the deserts of Morocco. They also often include lectures that explore a destinations history or a specific facet of the culture.